Materials Decision Guide
Hardwood vs Polycomposite: Which Should I Choose? gives homeowners straightforward plantation shutter guidance before, during, and after installation.
Find practical advice on measuring, fitting day preparation, cleaning, maintenance, and warranty support from a local shutter specialist.
The guide answers common questions clearly and helps you plan the right next step with confidence.
Last reviewed
Start with the real difference
Hardwood and Polycomposite both have a premium painted finish. On Plan & Save they are the same price; on Express, Hardwood is priced higher than Polycomposite.
The real difference is construction. Hardwood is real basswood. Polycomposite is a waterproof reinforced composite with better thermal and noise insulation. That makes Polycomposite the more practical premium product in many homes.
Hardwood remains useful when the customer specifically wants real timber character in a dry room. It should not be treated as the default upgrade; it is simply the right answer for a different priority.
Polycomposite wins when...
The room is humid, busy, or harder-working: bathrooms, kitchens, utility rooms, and conservatories are where waterproof Polycomposite is the clear recommendation.
You want the most practical premium product: Polycomposite has a reinforced core, wipes clean easily, and gives better thermal and noise insulation than Hardwood.
You want the longer material guarantee: Polycomposite carries a 10-year manufacturer guarantee against defects. Hardwood carries a 5-year guarantee.
Polycomposite also wins on insulation and noise
If the room is cold, exposed, noisy, or heavily used, Polycomposite is normally the better recommendation. The reinforced core gives better thermal and noise insulation than Hardwood while keeping the same premium painted finish.
This is especially useful on bay windows, street-facing bedrooms, conservatories, and family rooms where the shutters are doing more than dressing the window. They are helping the room feel calmer, more private, and easier to live with.
Hardwood makes sense when...
Real timber character is the priority. Hardwood is still a good product in dry rooms when the feel of basswood matters more than waterproofing, reinforcement, or insulation.
The room is a dry living room, bedroom, study, or formal reception space. In wet or condensation-prone rooms, Polycomposite is the right material.
You prefer the idea of real basswood. The finish quality is comparable with Polycomposite; the difference is the core material, Express price, and performance in harder-working rooms.
Most whole-house projects mix both
A typical four-bedroom installation might use Polycomposite in the family bathroom, en-suites, kitchen, and conservatory, then Hardwood in selected dry rooms where real timber character is part of the brief.
If you are unsure, bring physical samples of both to the room they would go in. We bring samples to every survey so the decision happens in your actual light rather than in a brochure.
Free Home Survey
Request a Free Home Survey
Fill in a few details and we'll be in touch to arrange a convenient time for your free consultation.
We usually reply within 24 hours
Contact Information
Call Us
0777 612 3386Email Us
info@shuttersdesign.co.ukAddress
20 Wittering CloseKingston upon ThamesKT2 5GAOpening Hours
Monday - Saturday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Sunday: Closed
Customer reviews
What our customers say
Verified Google reviews from recent Shutters Design customers across Surrey and South West London.
Inspiration
See real installations across Surrey
Real shutters fitted in real homes. Victorian bay windows in Kingston, kitchen fronts in Twickenham, full-height living rooms in Richmond.


Full Height, Living Room
Richmond
Full height shutters fitted to a wide bay. Louvres set to diffuse afternoon light while keeping the room private from the street.
Service Areas
Areas We Cover
We install plantation shutters across Surrey and South West London, measured and fitted by our own family-run team. The full list lives on the areas page; a dozen of our most-covered towns are below.
View all 50+ areasFAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
On Plan & Save, yes: both materials are GBP260 per square metre. On Express, Polycomposite is GBP315 per square metre and Hardwood is GBP380 per square metre. The material decision should still be based on room conditions and material priorities.
Polycomposite is the more practical premium product because it is waterproof, reinforced, lower maintenance, and better for thermal and noise insulation. Hardwood is better when real timber character is the main priority in a dry room.
We do not recommend Hardwood shutters for bathrooms or wet rooms. Polycomposite is the right material there because it is waterproof and stable around steam, splashes, and condensation.
Yes. Both materials have a premium painted finish. The difference is the construction under the finish and how the material performs in different rooms.